Overview

Mariner's Landing, nestled in the quaint town of Olcott, New York, offers a dining experience that captures the essence of a classic lakeside restaurant with a maritime charm. Located at 1540 Franklin Street, this establishment blends the rustic allure of a small fishing village with sophisticated seafood and steakhouse fare, making it a destination for both locals and travelers seeking authentic regional flavors.

The heart of Mariner's Landing is its menu, which showcases a thoughtful mix of hearty entrées and homemade soups, all crafted with care. Signature dishes like the New England Clam Chowder stand out for their rich, creamy texture—a true homage to coastal comfort food. The seafood platter combines fresh haddock, shrimp, and scallops flawlessly, emphasizing the brand’s commitment to quality and freshness. For those seeking a land-based alternative, the New York Strip and Filet Mignon offer tender, expertly prepared cuts, often paired with classic sides that complement without overwhelming.

Beyond the plate, the atmosphere plays a crucial role in the dining experience. Patrons often highlight the cozy, boat-themed décor that evokes a sense of nostalgia for small-town marinas. The restaurant’s setting extends its warmth through multiple seating options—from the bar and fireplace area to outdoor decks with serene views of the lake and park. This versatility makes it an inviting place whether you’re stopping by for a casual drink or settling in for a full-course meal with friends or family.

Service at Mariner's Landing has received mixed feedback, yet the common thread in reviews is the genuine hospitality and professionalism of the staff. While busy nights and special events can lead to longer wait times, the restaurant’s transparency about delays and commitment to quality meals seem to steady the overall experience. Families find the generous portions and kid-friendly options, such as chicken tenders, particularly appealing, further extending the restaurant’s reach beyond just seafood enthusiasts.

Mariner's Landing caters to a diverse audience—from out-of-town visitors attracted by the unique lakefront setting, to locals who appreciate a dependable spot for special occasions or relaxed dining. The incorporation of popular beverages like Guinness and Coca-Cola complements the menu well, tying together an experience that feels at once familiar and distinctly regional.

In summary, Mariner's Landing is more than a seafood restaurant; it's a vibrant chapter of Olcott’s culinary scene. Its blend of traditional seafood chowders, expertly grilled meats, and warm ambiance make it a noteworthy stop for anyone on the Niagara County dining trail. Whether you seek a romantic dinner, a casual family outing, or a scenic place to unwind with a drink, Mariner’s Landing offers a taste of both comfort and class, firmly anchored by its lakefront charm.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Small plates
Spirits
Wine
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy

What Customers Say

Kevin Casella
Jul 21,2025
4/5
Out of town visitor - Mariners was fantastic! The atmosphere in the restaurant is excellent. If youre looking for a small-town, fishing/boat themed place, look no further. Our wait was a little on the longer side, but we were warned when seated that would be the case. This was primarily due to an anniversary event for the location, so I expect that wasnt the "normal" wait times. Our party ordered a mix of mozzarella sticks, burger and fries, fish, and soup. All of it was fantastic and any dish that was beer battered was lights out. As a note - Our kiddo got the children's chicken tenders, and the helpings were very generous. The picture i posted was the size of the kids meal, not the adult dinner. We were very impressed. Our service was fantastic, with the waitresses doing very well despite how busy they were. Would absolutely recommend as a stop and will be coming back!
Kathy Eick
Jul 21,2025
5/5
Just enjoyed NYRS eve there. Food delicious, prices comparable, great service. So glad they have reopened! So love going there in the summer. Can't wait to go again.
JENNIFER LOIACONO
Jul 21,2025
5/5
Such a cozy restaurant with a beautiful view of the lake. The food is amazing and all homemade the chicken and biscuits are worth the ride out!
d cotten
Jul 21,2025
3/5
So, we read other reviews that mentioned the "slooow" service, but we decided to give it a try. Bad choice - we waited a full hour for our entres (after our salads were served). Two patrons at the bar that came in about a half an hour after us were served in about 10-15 minutes. A party of 10 that was seated after us were served first (this was confirmed by the staff). Lesson learned? If you're not a regular, expect second rate service. I will say the food was above average and I liked the ambiance - a throwback to a more elegant but faded seafood/steakhouse.
Joe Derda
Jul 21,2025
5/5
Always a pleasant experience. The food is always prepared to perfection. The entire staff is very friendly and professional. The menu is a mixture of lite for just a snack at the fully stocked bar, to full course dinners. You can choose where you want to eat, sit at the bar, sit by the fireplace in the bar area, sit in the wonderfully nautical decor of the dining room or weather permitting you can sit outside underneath the deck or up top with a fantastic view of the park and lake. Mariners Landing is just a totally wonderful experience.
Julian Urban
Jul 21,2025
4/5
The food was Great...had the Fresh Deep fried Perch and my Wife had the Seafood stuffed Cod along with seafood chowder and French Onion soup All Excellent. Sorry to say the service was sloooow. The seating and service were below normal and they seemed to be short-staffed. With that said, if you are an extremely patient person, it was worth the wait. Suggestion... get a drink from the bar first, this will ease the anxiety of the long wait.

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 04:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday 04:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More Restaurants in Olcott, New York, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!